More pp. on ideal of reason
Sku: 43500D0L060
Archival Number: A435 V310
Author: Lonergan, B.
Language(s): Latin,
Decade: 1960
Open 43500D0L060.pdf

Description:

More pp. on ideal of reason (I think).

4 handwritten schematic pp. All on reverse of discarded pp. on cognitional theory (A435a).  Dated Feb 27 1961. Again green ink. Note: the date is earlier than A434. There is a translation of this item by Robert M. Doran at 43500DTE060.


Database and descriptions © Copyright 2017 by Robert
M. Doran

Transcription:

 Transcription by Robert M. Doran


(page 1)

 

Sunt syllogismi – positis principiis, necessario sequuntur conclusiones

Sunt principia

Ergo manet ratio classica scientiae – saltem ut centrum stabile, universale abstractum

 

(1) Math          a  sunt systemata hypothetico-deductiva

                        b  axiomata petuntur  axioun  º postulata

                        g   Math  non quaerit de funda.

                                       debet esse multo plus exigens – princ. med. exc.

                                       debet manere in contactu cum motibus culturalibus

 

(2) Physica      observata ad leges

                                                                                    [diagram]

                        denique tandem ultimum criterium sc. phys. est elegantia

                                                                                                    simplicitas

 

(3) Academismus quod scientia est id quod addiscitur in seminariis

                                                                        communicatur in congressibus

                                                                        accipitur inter ‘competentes’

                             ultimum criterium est complexus conventionum

                                                                quae crisi non subiciuntur

                                                                quae non exacte formulantur

                             multominus quam mathematica vel physica

                             in sc. hum. qq reducuntur in philosophicas

                                                                        º instabiles [?]

 

(4) Ritualismus            Normae ex consuetudine magnorum editorum

                                                            eg in Britannia

                                                  ?  alumni [?]

 


(page 2)

 

(5) Philosophi scholastici contemporarii

            Crise de la raison  1960  Desclée

 

      R. Verneaux          p. 39    Thesis

                                                39-43   Leibnitz [?]                     

                                                43-45   Garrigou  Maritain   Descoqs

                                                45-48   non satis clare distinguitur a princ. ident.                                                                                                                                        causal

   

      S. Breton               p. 120  definition of crisis

                                        181  ML Roure       Logique et Metalogique

                                                                Lyon Vitte 1957 pp. 99-140

                                                ‘… que tout thomiste se devrait de méditer’

                                                principle of identity seems to admit no satisfactory formula

                                        182  la conscience et transcendent a toutes ses obiectivations [?]

 

     Contrast assumption of Verneaux & p. 182 of Breton

 

            is there or is there not a definitive irreformable metaphysics!

                                                exact definitions axioms conclusions

 

     Minor praemissa sunt principia      dist      exacte formulata irreformabilia           N

                                                                        inexacte formulata, reformabilia         D

                                                                        ita ut maneat linea fund. phil perennis A

                                                                        ut non maneat                                     N

 


(page 3)

 

Scotus             scientia est de omni mundo possibili

                        mundum actualis – voluntarismus

                                    ut sit ? quod systemati deductivistico irreformabili correspondeat

 

S Thomas        I-II 66 5 4m

                                    sc. conc ex praemissis

                                    int  praemissas ex term

                                    sap. seligit ordinat validat terminos fundam.

                        sap. donum SpSi - metaphys. Arist – correctio thomistica metaphys aris

 

            prout principia naturaliter nota                        ens

                        habitus naturalis principiorum quae sunt per se entis

 

                                                                                    [re these] scdm quod nat. cogn ab

                                                                                                            omnibus {conscientia

                                                                                                            ut transcendens

                                                                                                            obiectificat}

                                                                                                    scdm quod ??

 

Philosophia Xtiana      M. Nédoncelle            Encyclo XX  historicus           pp. 65-76

            re vera Blondel

Brehier            non magis quam math chim xtiana

            Gilson              historice exsistit

                                    de iure  auxilium indispensabile

                                    de facto  non constitutivum

                                   

 

            philosophia fit ab homine (in natura pura) circa hominem ( in nat pura)

 

Aquinas

            Theol                                       Theol

            phil arist                                  phil per se                    phil exsist

            sc arist                                     sc nat                           sc. human

 

si agatur de concreto, exsistente, praeter rem est deductio abstracta

                                                                                    de naturis ut sic

                                                                                    supernaturalibus ut sic

 

Agitur de reformulanda notione philosophiae et scientiae

                        conflictus inter phil et sc antiq                        et         phil et sc. modern

 


(page 4)

 

Theologia

 

manet unus Deus         sed   theologiae sunt multae

 

            dogmatica

            speculativa

            moralis

            pastoralis

            ascetica & mystica

            historia                        biblica

                                                patrist

                                                mediaevalis

                                                orientalis

                                                protestant

                                                religionum

 

effunditur in multa – in concreta – in historia – in dynamica

 

nisi theol spec-dogm ad concretum sese convertit

                        non potest esse ne ? regina sci

                                                 ne quidem regina theologiarum      [bold RD]

 

qui multi multis docent theologias, sicut docuit Husserl