Problema: Impulsus speculativus purus
Sku: 43700D0L060
Archival Number: A437 V315
Author: Lonergan, B.
Language(s): Latin,
Decade: 1960
Open 43700D0L060.pdf

Description:

6 handwritten schematic pp. Dated March 6 1961. Subjects: Problema pure speculativum, Traditionalismus, Quaestio, Distinctio, Summa Conflictus. All on reverse of (probably) pp of same essay as A435-436. All pp are in blue ink.


There is an English translation of this item by Robert M. Doran at 43700DTE060.

Database and descriptions © Copyright 2017 by Robert M. Doran

Transcription:

Transcription by Robert M. Doran 

Problema: Impulsus speculativus purus

 (page 1)

 Problema

             Impulsus speculativus purus

 

                        Anselmus Cant.           1033/34 – 1109

LTK I 592-4

FS Schmitt

 

                        omnia problemata speculativa fundamentalia

                                    de exsistentia Dei

                                    de trinitate                               monologicon   proslogion

                                    de casu diaboli

                                    de conceptu virginali

                                    cur Deus homo

                                    Dialogus de libro arbitrio

                                    Tractatus de concordia praescientiae

                                                Cap 11             ML 158, 522

 

                                                                        olim

                                                                        hodie – penitus desperant

 

                        “fides quaerens intellectum”  aureolam sanctitatis ab Anselmo accep

 

Problema pura speculativa

Problema pure ?

Quaestio

Distinctio

Summa

Conflictus

 


(page 2)

 

Traditionalismus

 

(1) sequimur    SScr, Patres                 i.e. addiscere nolumus

 

(2) Abaelardus                        1079 – 1142                LTK I, 55        Grillmeier

                        Sic et Non       ML      178      1329-1610

 

                                    Auctoritates sibi oppositae      circa qq 150

 

            Necessitas componendi

                                    solutionem speculativam ?      Anselmi

                                    cum doctrina traditionali eccl.

 

                        Aq vs Ans

                                    ? vs ? creditis

 

                                    traditio academica

 


(page 3)

 

Quaestio

            Y Congar        DTC    XV (29)           370-74 praes 371

 

                        1080 – 1154    LTK IV 890s  Lott     Editor. Haring

            Gilbertus Porret           comm in Boethium

 

                        ML 64 1253    Ex affirmatione et eius contradictoria negatione

                                                            quaestio constat

                                    1258    Requiruntur auctoritates pro utraque parte

                                                                        rationes

 

            St Thomas

                        Realis technica            De Ver 24 a 12            cf In II Sent d 28 a 2

                                                               23 & 11 – 34

                        Technica ?                   3 Videtur quod non

                                       ?                   q Sed contra                in Summa

 


(page 4)

 

Distinctio

 

(1) Sunt multae quaestiones

 

            distinguantur               P Lombardus   Quattuor libri Sent.     Patrum

 

                                                                        Distinctinis capita

 

            ordinantur                  

 

 

            reconcilantur   ?          Gratianus         Concordia discordantium Canonum

                                                                                                ? c 1142

                                                                                                            LTK IV

 

            a          relinquitur prudenti lectori

 

                                                º          Rouet & Denziger

 

                                                Thomas vs Anselmus

 

                                                            [T] vasta eruditio ex elaborativa praevia   ?

 

            b          ad mentem auctoris: problema historicum

 

            g          reverenter exponitur

 

M.D. Chenu    Authentica & Magistralia, Div Thomas 28 (1925) 257-85

 


(page 5)

 

Summa

 

(1) ita solvuntur quaestiones per distinctiones

            ut ipsae distinctiones novas non faciant quaestiones

 

(2) intrat elementum systematicum

            scil       distinctiones fiunt scdm

                                                                        terminorum fundamentalium

                                    complexionem             principiorum fundamentalium

 

 

(3) unde tota complexio          Aristoteles

 

            a          DB 410-483    actus

                                                habitus

 

            b          Supernaturale  Landgraf         Dogmengeschichte der Fruscho.

                                                Lonergan         Grat Op 1941

                                                Alzeghy           Greg 1950

                        adiectivum laudativum

                        theorema systematicum

 

            Summa theol. I 75 divine

                                      76  anima et corpus

                                      77-89   potentiae

 

                                    I-II      1-5       de fine

                                                6-48     de actibus

                                                49-89   de habitibus

                                                90-118 de lege

                                                109-14 de gratia

 
(page 6)

 

Conflictus                   F Ehrle                        John Pechkam             Zeit f Kath Theol

                                                                                                13 (1889)

             correctoria

            corruptoria

 Fr. Rogerii Marston                 QQ. DD.         Ad claras aquas 1932

            ob ca 1303

             systema hauritur ex modo loquendi Augustini

 E Gilson          L’augustinisme avicennisant

                        Pourquoi S Thomas a critique S. Augustin     Ad His doct litt

                        au M A

                      circa 1929-32

 (1) requiritur systema  secus reconciliationes reconciliari debeant

 (2) requiritur systema quod in ipsis fontibus saltem virtualiter adsit

 (3) apparentia systematis         id quod placet eclecticismo intelligentiae vulgaris

      Selbstverständlichkeit

(4) apparentia impossibilitatis systema = quoad se

                                                fontes = quoad nos kerygma

 [Reverse of this page has references:

             Augustinismus
Aristotelismus in MA  Fvan Steinbergen        LTK I 859-62]