Medieval Theology and the Modern Notion of Science
Sku: 43900D0E060
Archival Number: A439 V\3\18
Author: Lonergan, B.
Language(s): Latin,
Decade: 1960
Open 43900D0E060.pdf

Description:

4 handwritten schematic pp, back to green ink. No date. Many of the same topics as A437. A full p (2) treats the topic Summa, p. 3 Crisis, p. 4 Tragoedia, Possibilitas. On reverse of rejected pp of essay on realism (2 pp. of which are headed `The Analogy of Vision.' (Fay?) 


There is an English translation of this material by Robert M. Doran at 43700DTE060.

Database and descriptions © Copyright 2008 by Robert M. Doran

Transcription:

Transcription by Robert M. Doran
 

1  Evolventi notioni scientiae

2  cui exceptionem non facit ‘deductivismus’

 

3  additur theologia mediaevalis

 

            A.  Problemata            a theoretica – Anselmus

                                                b ex ipsis auctoritatibus – Abaelardus

 

            B.  Quaestio                a Sistuntur contradictoria

                                                b rationes seriae dictae[?] pro utraque parte

 

           C.  Distinctio

                         a  non una erat quaestio sed permultae – totus campus theologiae

                                    quod PP circa Trin., Incarn., Pelag.

                                                MA circa totam theologiam

                        b  distinctae qq.

                                    materialis divisio

                                    auctoritatum collectio

                                    forte aliqua reconciliatio         Lateran IV DB ?

             D.  Summa

                        ordinatio: functio        non qq

                                                            sed solutionum cohaerentium

                         inutilis est reconciliatio auctorit

                                         solutio problema                 si reconciliandae sunt reconcil

  solutiones nova faciunt probl

 

(page 2)
 

Summa

 

1  Arist            gratia   habitualis         DB 410, 483   Aq. est inceptor

                                   actualis                                      doctrinae de grat. act.

 

2  Ipsi theol.    supernaturale

                        naturale

 

            a          resolvit problemata secus insolubilia               Landgraf         Lottin

                       

            b          principia methodologica

                                    theologia tractat de ordine supernaturali

                                                                        cf DB 1795 s

                                                                        cf semi-rational

                                                                                    --  Anselm [?]

                                                                                    --  ? [?]

 

3  Transformatio aristotelis

 

            de potentiis     I, 77-89           de ente materiali          materia—forma—esse

            de actibus        I-II 6-48          de angelis        forma – cons [?]

            de habitibus     I-II 49-89        de Deo            esse subsistens

 

     a     Non solum de naturalibus sed etiam de spirit.

 

     b     Non PP ex Arist.         sensus – natura

                                                intelligentia – forma

 

                        Augustinus      verum – esse

 

                            evolutio dogmatis

 

     g     Ex prioribus quoad nos                       ad priora quoad se

                                            apostolos                  non categoriae biblicae

                                            primaevos xtianos    non categoriae patristicae

                                            patres

 

    d      ita in omni scientia      physica

                                                chimica

                                                biologica                      signum maturitatis [bold is RD]

                                                psychologica

                                                economica [?]

 


(page 3)

 

Crisis

 

1  essentia criseos       

 

            A inter traditionalistes                        priora quoad apostolos, patres, augustinum, se ipsos

 

                        motum scientificum    ? ad priora quoad se

 

            B  incapacitas aetatis ad ipsam crisin intelligendam

 

            Einstein: inspice quid faciant; nullo modo attendas ad ea quae dicunt

            Methodos: reflectio super solutionem, analysis viae qua processerunt

                        S Thomas fecit sed non explicavit quid fecisset

 

2  signa huius defectus intelligentiae

 

            a          Gulielmus de Tocco [?]           novos articulos

                                                                        novum modum determinandi

                                                                        novas rationes

                                                si comparantur Aquinas

                                                  et ?

                                                   ? lapidam      -  cathedrale

 

 

            b          priora quoad se non sunt verba Augustini

                                    derelinquitur Augustinus        John Peckham             DPCA  36

           

            g          acceptatur Aristoteles - materialiter & transformandus [?]

                                    per modum unius condemnati sunt Aquinas & Averroistae

 

                                                Stephen Tempier         18  I  1277

                                                Edwardus Kilwor? OP 18  III  1277

 

            d  correctoria   quaestiones marginales            de visione beata

                                                                                    de aeternitate mundi

                                                                                    de materia spirituali

                                                                                    de pluralitate formarum

                                                                                    de illuminatione intellectuali

                                                                                    de intellectualismo et voluntarismo

                        Gillon DTC 29, 658-93

                                    La signification historique 151-93

 

            ε  purus Augustinismus – Roger Marston OFM ob 1303 QQ.EE. Quaracchi

                purus quidam aristotelismus -  ? de Fontinus – Les philosophes belges

                augustinismus militans – Petrus Ioannis Olivi OFM

                                                            Durandus a S. Porciano O.P.  theologia inquisitionis

 

ζ decadentia et calamitas – Scotus,Ockham ???? DB 553-70

 


3  Tragoedia
            inceptum S Thomae non continuabatur
                   postquam canonizatio             18 iulio 1323
                        anno subsequenti licitum erat eius doctrinam Parisiensis defendere
                        next line unclear (Durandus?)
            inceptum S Thomae haud intelligebatur
                        priora quoad se – Aristotelis per accidens
                        acceptabatur organon Arist non spiritus scientificus
                        scientia moderna exire contra scholasticismum orta, evoluta est

 4  Possibilitas
            an exsistere
                 acceptari  potest systema priorum quoad se
            eo ipso quo est systematicum est rigidum, staticum, fixum
                                            excludit historia, evolut ?                                                            non potest includere evolutionem argumenti ?
            eo ipso quod respicit priora quoad se

chasma            sicut intra Lazarum

                                                                             divitem      

                                    evangelium vs theologia

                                    quoddam criterion possibile de methodo theologiae

                        &n