Accipe responsibilitatem iudicandi
Sku: 44800D0L050
Archival Number: A448 V336
Author: Lonergan, B.
Language(s): Latin,
Decade: 1960
Open 44800D0L050.pdf

Description:
5 handwritten schematic pp. in green ink on accepting the responsibility of judging. Last 2 on Falsa notio scientiae. Part of 1961 course De intellectu et methodo. On reverse of rejected pp. on realism.

English translation by RD at 44800DTGE060

Database and descriptions © Copyright 2017 by Robert M. Doran

Transcription:

by R. Doran

Accipe responsabilitatem iudicandi

 

Iudicium: Est, est – Non, non

            Non est complexio terminorum: in opinione alicui recitata    

                                                                  in hypothesi

                                                                  in fabula

            sed est absoluta positio term. complex – ego sum homo

                                                  term. simplicis – ego sum

 

Responsibilitas: non moralis proprie, universaliter, quia ipsa moralitas qiaedam iudicia supponit

            sed intellectualis: La Rochefoucauld

                        omnes de propria memoria queruntur

                        nemo de proprio iudicio

            Memoria non videtur esse in nostra potestate

            Iudicium est: possumus dicere Est, Non, Nescio certe, probabiliter

 

[page 2]

 

Momentum huius regulae

 

            - evitatio huius responsabilitatis in variis fontibus oritur

 

            - mechanizatio cognitionis / omissio subiecti

                        videmus res

                        conceptus rebus correspondent

                        videmus nexus inter conceptus

                        concludimus ex nexibus visis

                                    superfluit iudicium

                                                est assensus ad it quod ante iudicium cogniscitur

            quod falsum est

                        quia intelligentia praecedit conceptus

                                    intelligentia est multiplex

                                    conceptus de se non sunt cognitio

                                                              sed sunt cogitation

                                                (1) an universalia sunt realia

                                                (2) an part non existential sunt realia et probabilia

                                                (3) an datur ??

                                                (4) an ???

                                                (5) an datur ratio pura

                                    Sive An sit + Est

                                                Ex cogitatione ad cognitionem non pervenitur

 

[page 3]

 

Obiectivismus exaggerates: tendentiae logicae symbolicae

                                                sed sunt multae

            propositiones sunt verae obiective

            demonstrationes sunt validate obiective

                        quasi sit verum praeter mentem / fides scientifica

                                    quae Deus revelavit, sunt vera

                                    haec sunt vere revelata

                                    ergo haec sunt vera

                        quasi est demonstratio praeter mentem

                                      ? processus non rationalis sed obiectivus

                                    quo in processu requiritur responsabilitas iudicandi

 

obicit   res non demonstrator

            = res non cognoscitur sine cognoscente

 

[page 4]

 

Falsa notio scientiae:

 

(1) scientia est de necessariis

            re vera quod sunt essentiae finitae: contingens

                        quod sunt hae essentiae                     

                                    et non aliae paulo diversae      contingens

                        quod Deus exsistit quoad se necessarium

                                                       quoad nos: sunt contingentes: quod ? exsistit, quod ??, quod possumus deducere, quod de facto deducim.s

 

(2) scientia est de iis quae ab ? agnoscuntur

            (a) in naturalibus: in facto esse trans

                                          in fieri negatur eest contra omnes

                                          ab omnibus qui sunt ? ?

                                          ab omnibus qui sunt ???

            (b) in humanis ulterius intervenit subiectivitas

                        Historia catholica       

                                      protestantica              de iisdem rebus

                                      agnostica

                                      ??

                                      ??

                        Eadem historia sicutg eatem math, physica, chimica ??

            (c) subiacet effugium ex individualism scienifico

                        ad mentalitatem commune

                        indifferentiatio in quo non tam individuum sed tribus cogitate iudicat decernit

            (d) complexion est re theologia – de divinis iudicat sapientia: humana, nego; divina (another word?) concede

 

[page 5]

 

(3) empiricismus, positivismus, intuitionismus

            scientia est de datic, seculsa omni intelligentia

 

  (1) de facto si secludereter, intel [?] decernitur

  (2) eo verius judicare possumus, quo ? et plenius intelligimus

  (3) intentio exsistentiae

 

            Videtur OK – inspiciuntur in horto zoologico

                        (a whole line of very small handwriting that is illegible)

            ?

           

(4) Kantianismus

            (a) reicit intuitionismum – phenomenalismus ?? Berkeley

                                                                                         Illegible

                        res-in-se est incognoscibilis

                                       est conceptio-lismus: dicit quod nos cognoscimus

            (b) phenomena: formae a priori sensibilitatis                         

                                                                                                schematism

                                      categoriae intellectus: de se logicae

                                                unde experientia sine intuitione ?

                                                                            sined categoria – caeca

            (c) ratio - nullum

                        - facit ut plenus, completes sit ens: categorium, phenomena

                        - regula est ‘unconditionatum’ ex synthesi omni in conditione

            (d) obiectivitas = validitas = inconditionatum

                        non quasi perspicitur affirmatione absoluta à esse

                        sed: mens quam Deus Kant dedit, haec exigit

                               mens quam Kant descripsit autonomia et agit