Si Accipitur Responsabilitas Iudicandi
Sku: 44900D0L050
Archival Number: A449 V338
Author: Lonergan, B.
Language(s): Latin,
Decade: 1960
Open 44900D0L050.pdf

Description:
3 handwritten schematic pp in green ink, on what happens when one accepts responsibility of judging. Again, part of 1961 course De intellectu et methodo. On reverse of rejected pp. on realism.

English translation by RD at 44900DTE060

Database and descriptions © Copyright 2017 by Robert M. Doran

Transcription:

44900D0L060: transcription by R. Doran

 

Si acceptatur responsabilitas iudicandi

            quo criterio iudicatur?

            videtur quod totum relinquitur operationibus privatis

 

Resp. unico vocabulo – sapientia: omnia ordinat, omnia iudicat

            scientia de conc[lusionibus]

            intellectus de princ[ipiis]

            sapientia de term[inis

 

Object. pp 18 s. [RD: This probably refers to L’s notes from the first De intellectu et methodo, which he would have distributed for this second course]

 

(1) progressus humanus ad sapientiam, ad omnia, non est per additiones seu extrinsecas factas

            praecognoscitur totum ‘ens’   

            quod dividendo magis explicite cognoscitur

 

(2) divisio formaliter certa est ubi dividuntur contradictoria: arbor porphyriana

 

(3) divisio materialiter apta est ex augmento intelligentiae

            intelligentia vulgaris

            intelligentia scientifica            post initia tenditur in id quod permanenter valet

                                                                                    100 – 3.106

 

[page 2]

 

(4) Non est exigenda sapientia divina, quae pari securitate de omnibus iudicat

 

            ne sutor ultra crepidam

            tamen de calceamentis bene iudicat

 

            cognoscat, exploratas habet, omnes differentias actuales, possibiles

                        totum ? campum ordinatum

 

            sicut sutores, its etiam specialistae in singulis campis

 

(5) acquisita sapientia quadam partiali

            etiam additur insipientia evitanda [not sure of last two words] in caeteris partialibus

 

(6) non ideo tamen analogice de generali sapientia iudicamus et quasi fundatur in omnibus modo specialisato cognoscentis

 

(7) qualis sit haec generalis sapientia humana

            in facto esse: donum spS

                                    metaphysica Aristotelis

            in fieri: ? [question mark is Lonergan’s]

 

page 3]

 

(8) nostris temporibus problema maius ideo clarius

            (a) cognitio rerum particularium

                        conscientia indifferentia – sensus communis

                        circa generalia, fundamentalia : symbola

                        quae facilius fiunt mythi

            (b) cognitio theoretica

                        omnia technice definiuntur, unde ‘alius’ mundus

                        modo specializato – scientiae nat, hum

                        modo universali – metaphysica

                        problema de eorum habitudine inter se, cum sensu communi

            (c) cognitio subiecti, sui ipsius, structura: non metaphysica, non specializata, sed privata

                        unde (1) cognitio cognitionis: a, b, c

                                 (2) cognitio structurae obiectorum

 

cur isomorphismus: actus coalescunt ut cognitio; obiecta part. coalescent; coniuncta = medium ?